This essay originally was published on February 16, 2023 with the email subject line "CT No. 155: Medium, meet message."

For years, online businesses have depended on Google to drive audiences to their content. With something like 93% of global search market share at its peak, Google owned search engine use.

And why wouldn't it be the first focus for online businesses? For many years Google Search worked, Bing didn't feel like a serious alternative, and there were no other options to consider.

YouTube comment for a promotional video for Bing, which says "If I had a dollar for every time I heard someone say "Bing it," I'd have one dollar.
Youtube comment on this video, from when Microsoft did product placement for Bing

Leading search engine competitors — Bing, Baidu, Yandex, DuckDuckGo — didn’t even come close to sending the levels of traffic to online businesses that Google did.

But in 2022, Google's seemingly indestructible search product began to show cracks. First, more and more questions were asked about the quality of the search results. Engineers, press, the Hacker News crowd, and investors began to openly critique the search engine. Take this opinion, for instance, from venture capitalist Talia Goldberg:

Google search has deteriorated. Results are riddled with SEO arbitrageurs, ads, and affiliates. It pushes users to the highest bidders. It prioritizes its own results over organic links and prioritizes SEO-optimized sites over quality content. The quality and relevancy is declining. I am not the only one complaining.

As a professional SEO, I agreed in part. Searching for information on Google can feel like searching in the dark: you have to click open all the results to find the information you’re seeking.

But when I looked at the actual results for my employer — apart from the perceptions of writers and investors who don’t understand SEO or use analytics — I saw continued growth in traffic from organic search. For the business property I manage, I saw 47% traffic growth from organic search alone in 2022, compared to 10% growth in 2021. Other businesses are reporting all-time high traffic from organic search, indicating that audiences show no sign of abandoning the platform.

According to research from Growthbadger and corroborated by our knowledge of digital analytics, organic search is by far single largest online traffic source, driving over 50% of most industries' web traffic. Google specifically brings websites 8 times more traffic than all social media networks combined. If you’re looking to attract users to your website, organic search optimization, aka SEO primarily focusing on Google, is a safe bet.

It’s easy to critique Google and SEO if you don’t have experience with how it can drive serious growth to an online business with high-quality content, or if you’ve never audited your performance numbers. But we also know that the winds of change and a bottomless appetite for the next big thing can steer users — and investment dollars, online chatter and press perceptions — elsewhere. I had to ask: Why is everyone looking for a Google killer?

Many who are unfamiliar with digital marketing lump all search tactics together as “Google.”* But organic search (aka SEO) plays a very different role from paid search (aka search engine marketing [SEM] or pay-per-click [PPC]) in a digital ecosystem, so let’s establish the differences for the unfamiliar:

  • Organic search traffic: Audiences visiting from a search engine, where the visitor clicked on a “blue link” or other non-advertising search result.
  • Paid search traffic: Audiences visiting from search engines, where the user clicked an advertiser’s clearly marked search ad at the top of search results.

Businesses use Google as an intermediary between content they create and the audiences they serve. In a basic media strategy, paid search typically funnels audiences directly to product sales and purchase pages, while organic search supports broader brand initiatives like content marketing and audience development.

If organic search as a channel disappears or is eliminated, the digital media landscape would drastically change, especially for web-based content businesses.

*From our understanding, Google’s free organic search product data remains mostly separate from its far more invasive advertising and browser businesses. But many consumers just see the brand “Google” as a privacy-obliterating monolith and want to kill it off. Yes, the business units are all part of the same company, but the algorithms and personal data aren't all swimming in the same pool yet. Branding! It has an impact, especially for monoliths. —DC

Why are we looking for Google killers in the first place?

Why is there such avid speculation about the end of Google search? Four reasons stand out:

  1. Quality: Sometimes Google’s search results aren't great. The amount of search result pages occupied by paid search ads has grown over the years, as Google tries to monetize its cash cow. At least for some queries, it seems that non-experts can easily get a top-3 position in the search results in many industries.
  2. A psychological factor: people simply enjoy seeing a major player fail. It's an underdog syndrome, or an assumed David vs Goliath dynamic that can move markets.
  3. Privacy concerns: A search engine like DuckDuckGo positions itself as the better alternative to Google because it doesn't use any tracking (yet it never really took off with user adoption).
  4. Legal matters: There are, of course, all the lawsuits and legislation.

Let's take this shift seriously and review TikTok and ChatGPT as search engines: Will these new tools kill Google Search?

Search queries match search results

Before we dive into the disruptors, let’s understand the difference between search queries, search intent and search results.

The words that your audience types into a search engine are their queries: “blue pleated pants” or “how to unclog a sink” are all queries. A query can also be an image, voice prompt, or even an audio recording.

Editor’s note: Astute content professionals will note that a query is more commonly called a “keyword,” but at The Content Technologist we prefer “query" because it's more precise.

After a user submits a query, they receive search results. Different search engines display different results:

  • Spotify has audio results
  • YouTube has video results
  • Instagram has image and video results
  • TikTok has video results
  • Amazon has pages, but focuses solely on specific products

In web search engines, a search result is a list of links to websites, images or videos.

Intent is a major factor in organic search strategy. When someone types a phrase into the search bar, what do they mean? In SEO, we identify the following different search intents people may have when they type a query in Google:

  • Informational: Not all informational searches are the same. There are two types:

    Quick answer: I have a simple question with one answer: “How old is Barack Obama?”
    Research: I want to find in-depth information about something: “What are some digital strategies that work for businesses?”
  • Navigational or branded: I’m looking for a specific website and don’t know or don’t feel like typing in the URL: “amazon” or “content technologist”
  • Commercial: I’m looking to buy something, but I need more information first: “best slow juicer”
  • Transactional: I’m ready to buy something online: “buy vita extract slow juicer”
  • Local intent: I want to find a nearby location, often performed on a mobile device: “coffee place near me”

Search engines interpret intent based on the user’s query. It’s not always simple. For instance, if someone searches for: “pizza margherita,” are they looking for a recipe or do they want to order a pizza? Perhaps they are interested in the history of the dish.

Search engines use many different signals to understand the intent behind every search query, such as the device you are using, your location, and your most recent past searches. Producing the right result for each query at mass scale happens on a semi-personalized level, so if search engines don't already know your intent, they can guess.

Don’t misread the human behind the machine

Like machines, marketers and SEOs often misread their audience’s search intent.

Some examples:

Full article for paid supporters only. Upgrade to access.

Become a paid supporter for full access to remaining content, new articles weekly in your inbox, and hundreds of additional digital content strategy articles on The Content Technologist. No spam. We don't sell your data. By subscribing, you're helping us publish more original, independent and practical expertise from the pros at The Content Technologist.

Sign up now Already have an account? Sign in